Skip directly to Accessibility Notice
  • Gold Investing

    Gold’s 2019 Resolution: Challenge the Resistance

    Joe Foster, Portfolio Manager, Gold Strategy
    January 08, 2019

    Gold rides positive trend in December supported by trade conflict pause and rate hike

    After spending several months consolidating around the $1,200 per ounce level, we believe gold has embarked on a new positive trend supported by strong inflows to bullion exchange-traded products. Early in December the gold price gained with other commodities when President Donald Trump and China’s President Xi Jinping communicated a pause in their trade conflict. Gold then rose to six-month highs following the Federal Reserve’s decision to raise rates on December 19. The stock market, crude oil, bonds, and President Trump all signaled that Fed Chairman Jerome Powell had made a grave mistake by indicating more rate increases to come in 2019. We also believe that the Fed made a serious mistake, but we think the blame should be placed on Mr. Powell’s predecessors, who waited far too long to normalize monetary policy. Now the Fed is tasked with normalizing rates late in the cycle, and it is rapidly running out of time.

    Since the stock market peaked on September 21, gold has outperformed West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude oil by 42% and the NYSE Arca Gold Miners Index (GDMNTR)1 has outperformed the S&P 500® Index2  by 27%. Markets are beginning to price in an end to the post-crises expansion in 2019, while gold, the U.S. dollar, and U.S. Treasuries are all signaling a rise in global financial risks. For the month of December, gold gained $59.95 (4.9%) to $1,282.45 per ounce. Gold stocks trended higher with gold, as the GDMNTR advanced 10.8% and the MVIS Global Junior Gold Miners Index (MVGDXJTR)3 gained 13.1%.

    U.S. dollar strength was main headwind for gold’s disappointing 2018

    Excluding December, it was a difficult year for gold and gold stocks. The U.S. dollar was stronger than expected in 2018, which created a major headwind for gold. The U.S. economy received a boost from the Trump tax cuts and deficit spending, resulting in strong growth, low unemployment, and an annual gain of 4% for the US Dollar Index (DXY).4 Investors showed little interest in gold investments amid the booming economy and stock market highs. Rising rates coupled with the strong U.S. dollar created problems for emerging markets debt, which culminated in a currency crisis in Turkey. The U.S. dollar saw additional gains against many emerging markets currencies that are not included in the DXY. Weak fundamentals caused the gold price to fall through technical support to its yearly low of $1,160 in August. However, gold cut its losses late in the year, as market sentiment seemed to change to favor gold. Gold ended 2018 with an annual loss of just $20 (-1.6%).

    Gold stocks suffered this year despite strong financials and attractive valuations

    The lack of interest in gold for most of the year was magnified for gold stocks. The GDMNTR fell 8.5% in 2018, while the MVGDXJTR declined 11.3%. It was a particularly difficult year for junior companies, which we define as developers and those companies producing less than 300,000 ounces per year. Most juniors failed to outperform the GDMNTR benchmark. Tax loss selling and liquidation of a large gold fund weighed on juniors in the fourth quarter. The weak stock performance belies the fact that companies are doing well both operationally and financially. This has resulted in valuations that are well below the long-term average. Strong company fundamentals suggest that this value gap could close once investors take a more positive outlook for the gold price.

    Operational issues and geopolitical concern in Mexico impacted performance this year

    Our active gold strategy performance did not meet our expectations in 2018, even though we had some strong winners. Mid-tier producer Kirkland Lake (10.2% of net assets*) was able to expand high-grade reserves and production, resulting in strong gains for our top position. Several of our Australian mid-tier stocks also outperformed thanks to strong operating results. Our top junior developer Corvus Gold (2.3% of net assets*) advanced as the company published a robust preliminary economic assessment for its project in Nevada. However, we had a number of junior and mid-tier companies in the portfolio that reported unanticipated operating or social problems that impacted performance. When we invest, we are convinced through our due diligence that management can mitigate operating and social risks. Thus, when companies fail to operate as planned, we must determine whether it is a temporary issue or a lasting problem for management. In 2018, we had seven companies that failed to properly manage risks, which is more than double the norm. Four of these are no longer in the portfolio, while we expect three to regain their lost performance in 2019.

    A second area of underperformance was due to geopolitical risks associated with incoming President Andrés Manuel López Obrador of Mexico. It was anticipated that the new president would be unfriendly to business and could empower unions and anti-mining groups. Because of this, we trimmed our exposure to companies with Mexican operations ahead of the June election. However, after the election and before he took office in December, a controversial airport referendum and proposed anti-mining legislation from his party caused stocks to decline. In hindsight we should have been more aggressively cutting Mexico. Our Mexican exposure will remain below normal until we see more favorable leadership.

    Contrary to last year, 2019 is beginning with global contraction theme

    What a difference a year makes. 2018 began with the synchronized global growth theme and 2019 looks like it is beginning with a synchronized global contraction theme. Manufacturing results in China, as measured by the Purchasing Managers’ Index (PMI)5 from both the official Chinese National Bureau of Statistics and Caixin/Markit, a private survey, slipped into contraction territory in December. Japan and Germany logged negative GDP growth in the third quarter. According to a Duke University survey, as reported by Gluskin Sheff,6 49% of U.S. chief financial officers believe the economy will begin a recession in 2019 and 82% are expecting a recession in the next two years. Parts of the U.S. Treasury yield curve have slightly inverted, which has not happened since 2008.

    During the post-crisis bull market, the S&P 500 has endured four corrections of 15% to 20%, with the first three occurring in 2010, 2011, and 2015/16. The current correction is the fourth in this cycle and appears to be the most ominous forecast for the economy because it coincides with steep selloffs in crude oil and other commodities, along with a rally in U.S. Treasuries and widening corporate spreads. After a tax cut-induced surge, corporate profits are set to decline, which may foreshadow a fall in the largest single source of demand for U.S. stocks. Goldman Sachs reported in October that U.S. corporations were on track to repurchase over $770 billion of their own stock in 2018.

    Upcoming Fed action could go two ways and both appear favorable for gold

    It is widely believed that there is a 12-month lag for central bank policies to take effect. That means that the economy will feel the full impact of the Fed’s 2018 rate hikes and $30 billion of monthly quantitative tightening (QT) in 2019. In addition, the Fed is set to raise rates further and has increased QT to $50 billion per month.

    We expect to see one of two scenarios in 2019:

    1. The Fed stays on course, possibly driving the economy into recession. This may bring increased financial risks from highly-indebted governments and corporates.
    2. The Fed pauses or reverses its tightening cycle. This would likely bring U.S. dollar weakness.

    Both scenarios would be favorable for gold. Gold and gold stocks enter the New Year with positive trends that were lacking for most of 2018. In our opinion, it looks increasingly likely that gold may again test the $1,365 level of resistance that has been in place now for five years. If the markets are seeing enough systemic risks to move gold through this level, we believe it should be a very good year for investors in gold and gold stocks.

    Bear market not crash more likely and gold investments could be less volatile

    Finally, if we are correct in calling for a recession to start in the coming 12 months, would markets crash as they did in 2000 and 2008, or would it be a more orderly bear market? Barring a black swan event and aside from cryptocurrencies, there are not any obvious manias in this cycle. However, there has been asset price inflation in stocks, bonds, real estate, and other asset classes. In totality, this has possibly created the largest asset bubble in history, but without mania psychology, a crash is less likely in our view. An added risk in this cycle is an explosion of sovereign debt. This may bring a policy response from central banks in a downturn that distorts and drives markets, but we believe it is unlikely to precipitate a crash, especially with a more stable post-crisis banking system. Gold investments may see less volatility in a crash-less downturn.

    Download Commentary PDF with Fund specific information and performance