Key Takeaways:

• Analyst sentiment—measured through revisions to earnings, price targets, and ratings—has historically shown a persistent return premium across developed markets.
• The VanEck MSCI EAFE Analyst Sentiment ETF (VEFA) systematically captures this signal while targeting low ex-ante tracking error (≤4%) to the MSCI EAFE Index.
• The fund is designed as an enhanced core international allocation, offering diversification beyond U.S. equities with a forward-looking factor tilt.

Most investors access international developed market equities through passive index funds that make no distinctions between companies, or through active managers whose process can be difficult to evaluate. The VanEck MSCI EAFE Analyst Sentiment ETF (VEFA) is a third option: a rules-based ETF that systematically tilts toward stocks where professional analysts are most actively raising their expectations, while keeping risk anchored to the MSCI EAFE benchmark.

The Analyst Sentiment Return Premium

When professional sell-side analysts revise their views by raising earnings estimates, lifting price targets, or upgrading ratings, stocks with the most positive revision momentum have historically generated meaningfully stronger returns than those at the bottom of the sentiment spectrum. This relationship between analyst sentiment and subsequent performance is consistent across developed markets and has persisted through varied market environments.

The chart below illustrates the excess return spread across analyst sentiment deciles within the MSCI global universe as represented by the MSCI ACWI IMI Index. Stocks in the highest decile of analyst sentiment have consistently outperformed the index and those in the lowest decile. This is the signal that the MSCI EAFE Analyst Sentiment Select Index is built to capture.

Analyst Sentiment Exposure–Return Relationship

Source: MSCI. Returns based on MSCI ACWI IMI Index from June 29, 2007, to March 31, 2026. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Index performance is not representative of fund performance. It is not possible to invest directly in an index.

Why Analyst Sentiment Stands Out as a Compelling Factor

Not all factors are created equal. Analyst sentiment has a set of characteristics that distinguish it from more widely implemented smart beta approaches and that help explain why the return premium has proven durable. Below are the four properties that make it a systematic way to capture and leverage the evolving opinions of sell-side analysts.

• Forward looking: Identifies companies with improving forward fundamentals by capturing changes in earnings expectations and valuation outlooks. This is in stark contrast to most traditional factors like growth, value and momentum, which use backward-looking data to determine the factor score.
• Distinct: Changes in expectations have historically been associated with persistent excess returns, reflecting improving business outlooks. This persistence distinguishes analyst sentiment from price-based signals, which tend to revert, and from static fundamental screens, which lag actual business inflection points.
• Resilient over multiple time frames: Improving fundamentals have driven returns across market cycles and macro environments. Unlike cyclical factors that outperform only in specific regimes, analyst sentiment has shown consistent efficacy across rising rate periods, growth slowdowns and periods of elevated volatility.
• Systematic: Rules-based index designed to systematically capture companies with improving prospects, while remaining investable and scalable. The process removes discretionary judgment from stock selection, ensuring consistent application of the sentiment signal across every quarterly rebalance.

What is Analyst Sentiment?

Analyst sentiment captures how the views of professional sell-side analysts are changing over time. When analysts raise their earnings estimates, lift their price targets, or upgrade their ratings on a stock, that reflects a shift in their view of the company’s forward outlook. The opposite is also true: falling estimates and downgrades signal deteriorating expectations.

VEFA’s underlying index tracks these shifts systematically. Rather than relying on a single data point, the signal equally weights five distinct analyst revision types.

By aggregating across all five equally weighted inputs, the signal captures a more complete picture of how professional opinion is shifting. Stocks showing broad improvement across multiple inputs receive the strongest positive signal, identifying companies where the analyst community is broadly becoming more optimistic, not just selectively.

Separating Analyst Bias from Analyst Signal

The Bias Critique Targets the Wrong Metric

The question of whether sell-side analysts are structurally biased is a fair one, but it targets the wrong metric. VEFA does not rely on analyst ratings or absolute opinion. It tracks the direction of revisions, which means the question of whether analysts skew optimistic is not the relevant one. The relevant question is whether their views are improving or deteriorating, and on that dimension the signal has been consistent.

A stock being upgraded by its analyst coverage tells you something different than one sitting at a longstanding consensus buy with no recent activity. VEFA captures that directional shift across five metrics simultaneously: earnings estimates, price targets, sales forecasts, cash flow projections and ratings changes. Whether any individual analyst is optimistic or pessimistic in absolute terms is not the variable that drives the strategy.

It is also worth noting that analyst estimates are public, timestamped and tracked against outcomes by independent data providers. Analysts who miss consistently tend to lose institutional votes and coverage mandates over time. That creates a degree of accountability that reinforces the integrity of the underlying signal, even if it does not guarantee accuracy in any individual case.

A Rules-Based Approach to Capturing Analyst Sentiment

VEFA tracks the MSCI EAFE Analyst Sentiment Select Index, which takes the analyst sentiment signal and builds a portfolio through an optimization process. The objective is to maximize exposure to high-sentiment stocks within strict risk constraints designed to keep the fund usable as a core international allocation.

The 4% tracking error ceiling is a core design feature. High-tracking-error factor portfolios can deviate significantly from investor expectations, making them difficult to hold through periods of underperformance and harder to integrate as a primary building block. VEFA is constructed to behave like an enhanced EAFE core, not a concentrated tactical bet.

Why EAFE, and Why Now

There are two reasons to pay attention to international developed equities right now.

First, diversification. U.S. equities have become increasingly concentrated in a small number of large technology companies. International developed markets offer a broader, more balanced sector mix and significantly less single-stock concentration, which can help reduce overall portfolio risk.

Second, the trend is starting to shift. After more than a decade of U.S. dominance, international stocks are beginning to gain ground. The performance gap between U.S. and ex-U.S. developed markets peaked in late 2024 and has started to narrow, and there are growing tailwinds for international equities heading into 2026. For investors who have been underweight international stocks, this may be a favorable time to revisit that allocation.

MSCI EAFE Index versus S&P 500 Index

Source: Morningstar as of 03/31/2026. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Index performance is not representative of fund performance. It is not possible to invest directly in an index.

Investing in VEFA

For investors looking to put that tailwind to work, VEFA offers a direct way to access it. The VanEck MSCI EAFE Analyst Sentiment ETF tilts toward the stocks where professional analysts are most actively raising their expectations, while keeping risk anchored to the MSCI EAFE benchmark. The result is a fund built for investors who want international developed market exposure that goes beyond passive beta, without taking on the unpredictability of a high-conviction active manager. To learn more about VEFA or to invest, visit vaneck.com.

To receive more Emerging Markets Equity insights, sign up in our subscription center.